P02 final acceptance: CI #72 verified Redis durability and CSV replay safety (#3)

fix(p02): close verified Redis ACK and CSV replay acceptance [skip ci]
This commit was merged in pull request #3.
This commit is contained in:
victorsteele428 committed 2026-11-22 11:49:06 +00:00
1 parent fd57a3518d
commit 48fb277079
11 files changed
+799 -25

No files matched your search

+46 -2
View File
@@ -2,13 +2,13 @@
Frozen source baseline: `d725841ebc828d58cbe90f517da9e600f23c4630`. Generated: 2026-11-22 Asia/Dhaka.
Scope: documentation-only kickoff. Any future phase must update this log **after** verification, not on intention.
**Completed implementation phases: 1 / 3. Remaining: 2.** Documentation baseline preparation is a separate non-implementation milestone.
**P01 CLOSED; P02 verified in Gitea CI #72 and awaiting recorded three-remote publication; P03 NOT STARTED.** Publication/tree-parity proof and final phase-close status are recorded in the latest acceptance appendix and operator report.
| Phase | Status | IDs / function | Changed source | Verified CI evidence | Commit / remote sync |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P00 Notes / freeze | COMPLETED (documentation only) | `001–006` docs, source baseline and exact scope | `notes/**` only | 6 Markdown files; balanced fences; staged diff `--check` PASS | Documentation commit containing this file; remote SHA verification recorded in session handoff |
| P01 Tests & lockfile | **CLOSED — VERIFIED** | CI-01…CI-05, no runtime feature changes | 16 exact P01 code/test/CI paths, plus `notes/001–006` records | #59 Linux/Windows clean npm/SDK, 24/24 TS suites, Next standalone PASS; #60 strict TypeScript and ESLint PASS; historical #59 quality mismatch corrected | One permanent P01 main commit containing these notes; confirm remote SHA/tree parity in phase handoff |
| P02 Ingestion reliability | **BLOCKED — three diagnostic cases reproduced; runtime fix requires separate approval** | R-01 ACK/RAM loss; R-02 CSV duplicate replay; R-03 health liveness vs readiness | Only `tests/phase02-sync.test.ts` and `tests/phase03-storage-buffer.test.ts`, plus notes/001–006 | Gitea #63: all three P02 subtests PASS to reproduce existing behavior; full matrix status recorded in appendix | Diagnostic branch `p02-readiness-test-20261122`, no production runtime changes |
| P02 Ingestion reliability | **CI VERIFIED #72 — final publish gate** | R-01 ACK/idempotency safety; R-02 CSV replay; R-03 liveness verified unchanged | Exactly 3 runtime files, 2 tests, notes/001-006 | #72 terminal SUCCESS: 24/24 TS, TS typecheck, lint, Next standalone, Windows SDK | Final source/test acca8be01a31f8d3972564cbaec8fd3117a0b551; three-remote main parity recorded on publication |
| P03 CI/Docker/security | NOT STARTED | CI-06,07,08; release gates | None | Not run | — |
## Existing diagnostic CI snapshot (NOT implementation phase completions)
@@ -91,3 +91,47 @@ Historical baseline code stayed frozen through these CI workflow changes. Curren
- **BLOCKING RELEASE FINDINGS:** R-01 success ACK issued for non-durable RAM fallback when Redis RPUSH fails; R-02 identical eventId can append twice on post-CSV Redis-trim failure (web-side representative test). R-03 health remains online on Redis loss; liveness-only behavior is backward-compatible, protected dependency-readiness verification remains missing.
- **P02 PHASE = BLOCKED**, diagnostic implementation done, release reliability acceptance NOT satisfied. Runtime remediation requires separate exact approval. 1/3 phases still CLOSED (P01 only); P02 and P03 remain unclosed. No P03 start authorization from this diagnostic completion.
- Next approval must explicitly authorize exact narrow server/core patch for ACK durability and CSV replay deduplication, plus concrete no-loss/no-duplicate tests. Any readiness endpoint change needs separate explicit approval. User's initial P02 approval is insufficient for runtime mutation.
## P02-RUNTIME-REMEDIATION — Candidate implementation checkpoint (2026-11-22)
- **Current P02: BLOCKED / NOT CLOSED.** One previous diagnostic Gitea CI #63 reproduced R-01/R-02/R-03; runtime remediation was separately approved after that. Verified completed implementation phases remain **1/3** (P01 only). Do not approve P03 yet.
- Published P02 diagnosis baseline `fd57a3518d14bcb8367ce9ab9c3ec306bcfc9898`; isolated local candidate commit `44eee8877e40d1683f44502c2a0ba3d437a03b88` on `p02-runtime-remediation-20261122`.
- Exactly five code/test files changed in this candidate: `server/index.js`, `server/socket/handlers.js`, `core/data/buffer.ts`, `tests/phase02-sync.test.ts`, `tests/phase03-storage-buffer.test.ts`. No `server/workers/csvWriter.js`, `app/**`, `components/**`, SDK, public R-03 health, CI workflow, database, migration, production data, secrets or deployment touched.
- JS `node --check` on two changed JS files PASS; `git diff --check` PASS and allowlist audit PASS. Targeted TS/Node regression and Gitea CI **NOT YET RUN TO TERMINAL PASS**. The Gitea connector/host was unavailable when dispatch/push was attempted. Local temporary dependency installation also not yet complete.
- The original user PC root `D:\VibTools_Workspace\01_Products\14_DataStack` still has 16 pre-existing staged P01 paths on older `d8ac96e`; deliberately preserved without reset/stash/discard. All P02 implementation is in a separate temporary worktree. Do not assume the old local root is up to date.
- R-01 and R-02 implementations are candidates; practical reliability limitations and I/O cost recorded in `notes/001` and `notes/004`. No false claim of globally exactly-once CSV or universally durable ACK.
- **Next gates:** restore Gitea access; run one focused disposable acceptance; fix any in-scope test/TS defects; record exact CI terminal results; only after required acceptance and security audit, squash single phase main commit and verify GitHub/GitLab/Gitea tree parity; then, and only then, decide P02 CLOSED versus residual-risk blocker.
### Verification environment blocker — local dependency install
The authorized Windows PC attempted a **local disposable** `npm.cmd ci --ignore-scripts --no-audit --no-fund --prefer-offline` in the isolated P02 worktree only; it failed with `npm ERR! ETARGET No matching version found for yaml@2.9.1` plus cleanup EPERM warnings in the temp worktree's `node_modules`. Exact output captured in `%TEMP%\DataStack-P02-npm-ci.log` on the authorized PC. This is **not a passed code test nor proof of a repository package defect**, and `package-lock.json` / `package.json` cannot be edited under P02 scope. Gitea MCP remained UNAVAILABLE and the Git remote/HTTP service was not responding when CI was attempted, so the mandatory P02 focused CI was **not dispatched**. Phase remains BLOCKED pending actual CI evidence; no runtime change was pushed to production/main.
## P02-FINAL-ACCEPTANCE-01 Current Verification (latest record)
- **At this checkpoint: P02 acceptance PENDING CI #69**. P01 CLOSED; P03 NOT STARTED. Do not reinterpret earlier P02 BLOCKED audit as a completed release.
- Gitea #66 on `76cd972bdeea9ef07b4b38e9d8b5b5ed3312ca5b` **COMPLETED SUCCESS**: node-regression 24/24 suites PASS including direct Port4000 replay; quality (strict tsc+ESLint) PASS; production-build PASS; windows-compatibility SDK PASS; Python/Docker skipped by scoped `p01_only` input.
- Final patch `bf525f0d4e5e4781de7fddd2f5e7d3d602a80532` in clean isolated `p02-final-acceptance-20261122`: resolved source-grounded negative-marker TTL bug and mixed-batch success ACK, plus test-only stale-claim time jump (+61s), failed Redis claim, mixed batch, intentionally Redis-free compatibility, rotated .csv.gz+multiline replay and partial-corrupt CSV fail-closed/recovery. No source outside `server/socket/handlers.js` changed since candidate.
- One focused Gitea CI #69 dispatched for final patch; job terminal outcome and any corrective action must be recorded. **Do not merge until this passes and exact patch/security audit is reviewed.**
- Original `D:\VibTools_Workspace\01_Products\14_DataStack` at old `d8ac96e` with 16 staged P01 changes untouched. Separate pre-existing `p02-runtime-remediation-20261122` had three dirty files; left untouched. The new isolated worktree was created clean from candidate SHA.
- Source behavior: no Redis configured = historical RAM best-effort acceptance preserved; configured Redis failure = negative ACK; public /health unchanged. Per-CSV replay scanning bounded-memory but linear in stored bytes; no global exactly-once/throughput guarantee. P03 cannot begin until P02 acceptance/remote parity close.
### P02 Focused Retry — #69 fixture failure / #72 correction
- Final acceptance CI #69 on `bf525f0d4e5e4781de7fddd2f5e7d3d602a80532`: node-regression **FAIL** because `phase02-sync` stale-marker test globally mocked `Date.now` and Socket.IO ACK timed out. Other new tests for gzip/rotated CSV, partial CSV corruption, Redis-free RAM and mixed batch with a new persisted event PASS. Strict TypeScript, lint and Windows SDK jobs PASS; full workflow conclusion must be read at terminal.
- New source-grounded all-duplicate mixed batch path (`processed=0`, `duplicates=1`, `rejected>0`, volatile claim present) could return overall success; added focused test and changed handler conditional to reject all `volatileDuplicate` combinations.
- Test correction removes process-wide Date.now override, verifies 61000ms/300000ms cleanup math with static source marker assertion, and checks real Socket.IO negative retries. No unrelated files, CI workflows, SDK, auth or public health modified.
- Commit `acca8be01a31f8d3972564cbaec8fd3117a0b551` submitted to disposable CI #72; **P02 remains pending / NOT CLOSED** until terminal acceptance and 3-way mirror parity.
## P02 Verified Acceptance and Conditional Publication — 2026-11-22
- **Code acceptance VERIFIED — Gitea CI #72 terminal SUCCESS.** Code SHA `acca8be01a31f8d3972564cbaec8fd3117a0b551`. Node regression exactly `CI_SUITE_SUMMARY total=24 failed=0`, individual `tests/phase02-sync.test.ts` and `tests/phase03-storage-buffer.test.ts` suites exit 0. Quality strict TS+ESLint, Next standalone build and Windows Node SDK jobs all SUCCESS. Python/Docker intentionally skipped in this focused P02 workflow.
- **Root causes fixed:** configured Redis RPUSH outage returns `BUFFER_PERSIST_FAILED` negative ACK rather than volatile RAM success; stale failed idempotency claim retains correct TTL and remains negative through retries; `batch_sync` with old durable duplicates plus failed volatile claim returns `success:false`; CSV-before-Redis-LTRIM replay suppresses previously written same-client/date/eventId across plain/rotated/gz CSV with multiline quoted payload; corrupt matching CSV prevents Redis trim and can be recovered after disposable repair.
- **Explicit limits:** Redis intentionally unconfigured retains historical best-effort RAM ACK; no globally atomic exactly-once promise; scan I/O proportional to matching partition bytes even though memory streaming; public /health continues liveness not dependency readiness; live production unknown. No deployment, migration, secret access, user-data mutation, tag, release or build of production images.
- **Historical testing:** #66 PASS candidate; #69 suite failure (Socket.IO ACK timeout caused by test-only global `Date.now` override) and cancellation; #72 PASS corrected source/test. No false claim that #69 succeeded.
- Final code/diff safety audit: 11/11 approved paths only: `server/index.js`, `server/socket/handlers.js`, `core/data/buffer.ts`, `tests/phase02-sync.test.ts`, `tests/phase03-storage-buffer.test.ts`, plus `notes/001–006`; `git diff --check` and JS syntax PASS. Original PC root old staged P01 (16 paths) and separate dirty earlier temporary worktree preserved.
- **Publication gate:** Gitea PR #3 final verified source + documentation notes; squash-merge with `[skip ci]`, publish to GitHub and GitLab, verify identical tracked Git trees despite potentially different GitLab commit SHA. P02 marked CLOSED only after three-remote content parity; evidence SHA/tree in operator's final publication report. P03 NOT STARTED and requires separate approval.